Giving Thanks at Work: How Each Enneagram Type Wants to Be Recognized on a Team
Thanksgiving is around the corner, so it’s a good moment to pause and feel gratitude for the things that make your life better. Given that we spend almost one quarter of our waking hours at work, some of this gratitude should probably go to the folks you work with. Studies show that gratitude is good for your health, but whether you are the top dog in the office or the newest arrival, saying “thank you” to the people you work alongside is also good for your office relationships.
One thing people don’t always realize is that the compliment that makes someone’s day might sound totally fake and disingenuous to someone else. “Getting generic praise actually demotivates me,” Sharon, a Type Three, told me. “I had a boss observe the first ten minutes of my presentation and then leave since he felt it was good. That was a total trigger for me since I had put so much effort into the whole thing. I felt like his bar wasn’t high enough, and it made me discount all of his feedback.”
To avoid making that innocent faux pas, it helps to understand what motivates someone. Let’s use the Enneagram as a guide to understand how each type wants to be recognized at work.
Type One: Perfectionist
People think of Ones as the adult of the team, and their contributions keep quality standards high. Their sense of personal responsibility runs deep, and since they take their job so seriously, a meaningful compliment is like shining a light on a tiny closet corner they’ve tirelessly kept clean without anyone asking. But because they have such exacting standards, the wrong compliment can do more harm than good.
What Doesn’t Land: “Nice work on the handbook update. It looks great!”
A generic “great job” can feel devastating to Ones since it suggests their boss has no idea of the effort behind the output. That employee handbook was 300 pages long, and they edited every single page, including the footnotes. Even worse is a compliment for a job the One themselves think was substandard. This can make a One question the speaker’s standards or even their honesty.
What Works: “The policy changes you built into the handbook are going to make a real difference in our healthcare plan. You were so balanced in your approach. I know it was a lot of late nights and revisions, but this updated version is going to serve as our foundation for the next decade.”
Being recognized not just for your job well-done but for their lasting contributions is music to a One’s ears. The greatest compliment is when the One knows that, in their own small way, they make the world a better place.
Type Two: Giver
Twos are team players and showing up for colleagues is one of their strengths. They tend to offer far more behind-the-scenes help than the rest of the team sees, and someone noticing and appreciating that is like oxygen to them. A thoughtful compliment means more to a Two than most colleagues would guess.
What Doesn’t Land: “You sacrifice so much for the team. We know you’ll answer our messages 24 hours a day, and we appreciate you coming in on the weekends any time you see the workload is getting intense.”
Being admired for how available they always are and how they bend over backwards to make sure everyone is supported is like pouring gasoline on a fire. Twos are being praised for the very things they need to stop doing. Their colleagues probably don’t realize how much all this support costs them physically, mentally and emotionally and how close they might be to burnout.
What Works: “You noticed Auburn was struggling before any of us did, and you rebuilt the project schedule so she could step back without the launch slipping. We still came in on time and on budget. That took real skill.”
Praise that highlights their capabilities as well as their high emotional intelligence makes Twos feel appreciated. It gets bonus points if the compliment is spontaneous and not just part of an annual review. Something as simple as a few words in the break room on a Thursday afternoon can give them the boost they need to keep going.
Type Three: Achiever
Threes have been called workaholics and are often the first to arrive and the last to leave the office. Recognition matters more to them than they would like to admit, and their secret hope is that colleagues see them as a success. Admiration feeds their efforts, so a public thank-you goes a long way.
What Doesn’t Land: “Thank you so much for diligently creating and sending our weekly marketing email. The graphics are outstanding!”
Praise for something small and routine can backfire. Is the speaker implying that this simple action was a significant feat? Were they unsure the Three could handle a task like that? The wrong compliment runs the risk of insulting them. The only thing worse is the “everyone is a winner” message, which also demotivates Threes.
What Works: “This week we wanted to highlight Samantha, the person behind the weekly marketing email. The open rate is over double the industry standard, and we believe this email is the lead magnet for over 40% of our annual sales.”
Getting recognition for creating that weekly marketing email feels small, but praise that ties it to the whole marketing department reaching its goals is the kind a Three takes to heart. Threes particularly appreciate praise delivered so everyone knows about their impact. They want the team to see their achievements, and a public shout-out does exactly that.
Type Four: Individualist
Fours bring depth and emotional honesty to the team, and they often notice what everyone else missed. Feeling seen matters more to them than being praised, so a compliment only counts if it proves someone was paying attention. They are on high alert for anything that sounds disingenuous or generic.
What Doesn’t Land: “We appreciate everything you bring to the table. Solid work, as always. Keep it up!”
Fours are allergic to phoniness, so stock phrases or generic praise make them wrinkle their nose. Seriously? Does the speaker see them at all? They would much rather hear nothing than something so vague it could apply to any of their colleagues.
What Works: “When you reframed the client’s complaint as a story about what they are afraid of, it changed how the whole team saw the project. I wouldn’t have gotten there on my own. I’m still thinking about it.”
The authenticity of the comment is the most important thing when someone thanks a Four. They pick up on every nuance of the exchange, from how directly the speaker looks them in the eye to how the speaker shifts on their feet. It all registers. A Four’s rule for praise is keep it real or don’t say it.
Type Five: Investigator
Fives are known for their rational, data-based perspective, and while they might be the quietest person on the team, they are likely also the one with the most subject-matter expertise. Success, in their eyes, is being knowledgeable and capable, so the most effective compliments speak to those values.
What Doesn’t Land: “You are the smartest person I know!”
A direct compliment about their raw intellect is uninspiring. Fives hear it the same way as a compliment about their natural hair color; it doesn’t warrant an acknowledgement because it has nothing to do with their contribution. Compliments in general don’t sway them, so to count, your gratitude needs to tell them something they don’t already know. Even worse is gushing praise delivered in front of the whole team. Being put on the spot drains a Five’s energy.
What Works: “You’ve been tracking generative AI since 2022, and your research has been crucial in helping our team choose the best tools. You’ve earned the trust of senior leadership, and our future plan is based largely on your insights.”
Ideally, the compliment is delivered in private, via a short email or a private word, which suits a Five better than public applause. They appreciate brief, factually accurate praise that acknowledges their specific knowledge-based contributions. Fives have likely spent years mastering their subject and hearing that others respect their expertise makes them feel proud and acknowledged.
Type Six: Skeptic
Sixes are the steady, reliable anchor of the team, and their loyalty shows. Their colleagues know they can count on them, often more than they realize. Sixes look out for the team by spotting problems early, and that foresight tends to go unthanked.
What Doesn’t Land: “You knocked that meeting out of the park! The way you presented the numbers is what I’m trying to do too. Can you help me with my report?”
Sixes are already a bit suspicious when it comes to praise. Kind words followed by requests confirm their belief that praise comes with strings attached. They are left wondering if the compliment was even sincere, and they’ll be turning it over in their mind for days looking for clues.
What Works: “You saw the supply chain weakness before the rest of us, and because you had already sourced two other vendors, we were able to meet all of our contract terms. Your contingency planning saved us a bunch of headaches and sleepless nights.”
A Six’s mind can add layers and projections to whatever words were said, so the more specific and unambiguous, the better. They appreciate praise that names the risk they caught and admits they were right.
Type Seven: Enthusiast
Sevens are the idea generators of the team, full of energy and possibilities that nobody else had on their radar. They think fast, connect dots quickly and can make even the dullest project more fun. Freedom matters to them, and they chafe at anything that feels like being managed.
What Doesn’t Land: “Good job! I am very pleased with how your quarterly report turned out.”
Sevens hate hierarchy, so anything that reminds them they have a boss can make their skin crawl. “I’m pleased” brings them flashbacks to their third-grade teacher grading their papers, and “good job” reminds them there is a pecking order on the team. Both can feel patronizing.
What Works: “Your idea to turn the quarterly report into an interactive game had the whole department buzzing. You did the impossible and made dry data fun. The strategy behind it was smart too. What would you do with the annual report?”
Sevens love being treated as an equal and a creative partner. They sometimes wonder if people take them seriously enough, so praise that also credits their strategic thinking means a lot to them. A real win is if the compliment opens a door to the next adventure. Nothing feels better to a Seven than being invited to dream bigger.
Type Eight: Challenger
Eights are often the most direct people on the team, and because they are so action-oriented, praise that isn’t actionable can confuse them. If anything, they might be left thinking, “What am I going to do with this?” If the boss is happy with their work, does the Eight get more responsibility? A raise? How does the praise translate into the practical work world?
What Doesn’t Land: “I just want to say how grateful we all are for everything you bring to this team. Your energy, your leadership and your vision really make a difference every single day.”
Long, flowery praise about their contributions can actually annoy Eights, and as they are sensitive to manipulation, an innocently delivered compliment might make them pause. They have been known to question the intention behind it. They hear a compliment and wonder, “What do they want from me?”
What Works: “The Baker account was one of our biggest failures, and you turned it around. I’m putting you in charge of the renewal negotiations for our top five clients.”
Words can be nice, but Eights prefer brief acknowledgments and then very real actions to support the words. Hearing praise about their initiative and contributions might encourage them to do more, but actions make them feel valued.
Type Nine: Peacemaker
Nines are probably among the lower-profile team members, but they are also often the glue that holds the group together. They listen to everyone, and in their understated way, they help make sure company projects are a success. Because so much of their contribution happens behind the scenes, praise that misses those details can leave them feeling overlooked.
What Doesn’t Land: “Great job on the new system rollout. Amazing, amazing work. You’re such a rock star!”
Overly effusive praise can make Nines flush red, as the spotlight feels uncomfortable. Too much praise can sound condescending, like the speaker doubted their capability. Nines aren’t driven by a need to be admired, but they do want others to see them as deeply capable.
What Works: “I noticed you stayed after the meeting to walk Joseph through the new system. Nobody asked you to do that, and it’s a big reason the rollout went so smoothly.”
Specific compliments of things they quietly did can go a long way. When a compliment makes it clear that someone is paying attention, it brightens a Nine’s world. Nines can sometimes feel invisible, so a low-key compliment that makes it clear they aren’t is really appreciated.
A Final Word
No matter what type you are thanking, a few universal rules hold true:
- Be specific, using direct examples whenever possible so the person knows you were really paying attention.
- When you can, back up the praise with practical action.
- Take care to match the delivery to the individual, whether it is a public shout-out or a private email.
With a little thought and effort, you can send a Thanksgiving message your colleague will always remember. And if you get it wrong? You can learn how to apologize based on each person’s Enneagram type.
Want to know how each person on your team likes to be recognized? Truity@Work lets you test your whole team with the Enneagram for the Workplace assessment, and each report is written in plain, jargon-free language. Setup takes minutes, and you can start with just a few tests. Visit Truity@Work.
Lynn Roulo is an Enneagram instructor and Kundalini Yoga teacher who teaches a unique combination of the two systems, combining the physical benefits of Kundalini Yoga with the psychological growth tools of the Enneagram. She invites you to join her in Greece for her Enneagram-themed retreats! She has written two books about the Enneagram (Headstart for Happiness and The Nine Keys) and leverages her background as a CPA and CFO to bring the Enneagram to the workplace. Learn more about Lynn and her work here at LynnRoulo.com.